The Witness Matrix: A Smart Strategy for Preparing Witness Interviews

If you’ve ever walked into a witness interview unsure how much time or energy to invest—this post is for you.

 

In the world of workplace investigations and compliance inquiries, not all witnesses are equally helpful. Yet too often, investigators use the same approach for every interview. That’s a recipe for wasted time and missed insights.

 

The Witness Matrix is a practical framework that helps investigators quickly assess and prepare for different types of witnesses. It’s based on two key factors:

  • Cooperation – how open, responsive, and engaged the witness is
  • Knowledge – how much relevant, first-hand information the witness holds

When mapped together, they create a clear strategy for investigative interviews:


  • Engaged Insider – High cooperation, high knowledge
  • Guarded Insider – Low cooperation, high knowledge
  • Helpful Outsider – High cooperation, low knowledge
  • Uninformed & Unhelpful – Low cooperation, low knowledge

This matrix is a game-changer for investigators who want to plan effective interviews, focus on the right people, and improve the quality of evidence gathered.

 

1. Engaged Insider: Your Ideal Witness

 

These witnesses are cooperative, knowledgeable, and motivated to help. Treat them well and they’ll often go above and beyond.

  • Use open-ended questions to invite rich detail
  • Respect their time and acknowledge their insight
  • Keep them updated if it’s safe and appropriate to do so

Engaged Insiders are often the backbone of an investigation. With the right approach, they can help connect dots and point you to additional leads.

 

2. Guarded Insider: High Risk, High Value

 

These individuals know what happened—but they’re not eager to talk. It could be due to fear, loyalty, or personal risk. Rushing the process won’t help.


  • Build trust slowly and respectfully
  • Ask indirect or scenario-based questions
  • Be transparent about process and protections

They may become more cooperative over time—especially if they feel safe and fairly treated.

 

3. Helpful Outsider: Cooperative but Limited Insight

 

This type of witness is eager to help, but usually on the fringe of the core issue. That said, their observations can still be valuable.

  • Focus questions on what they directly experienced
  • Reinforce that even small insights can be helpful
  • Use them for context and corroboration, not discovery

When scoped properly, Helpful Outsiders can support your overall findings.

 

4. Uninformed & Unhelpful: Don’t Get Stuck Here

 

These witnesses lack both cooperation and knowledge. Whether they’re unmotivated, disengaged, or simply not relevant, recognize the signs early.

  • Keep the interview short and focused
  • Use a neutral, professional tone
  • Stay in control and close the interview promptly if it’s going nowhere

Spending too much time here risks derailing the investigation and draining your energy.

 

Why the Witness Matrix Matters

 

Using this simple matrix, investigators can:

  • Prioritize interviews based on cooperation and knowledge
  • Customize their approach for each witness
  • Avoid wasting time on dead ends
  • Gather stronger, more reliable evidence

Whether you’re conducting internal investigations, compliance reviews, or misconduct inquiries, this tool helps you approach interviews strategically—not reactively.

 

Need Help Preparing for Witness Interviews?

 

At STB Integrity, we help professionals plan and conduct investigative interviews that get results.

 

Our training includes practical frameworks—like the Witness Matrix—that give you the tools to navigate difficult interviews, manage risk, and get to the truth faster. Contact us for for custom support. We’ll help you walk into every interview with confidence.

Liked this post? Get even more insights. Join the Integrity Career Institute Newsletter!


Every week, we dive deeper into topics like this, sharing exclusive insights, expert tips, and hand-picked opportunities in investigation, ethics, and compliance.


Ready take your expertise to the next level?

SIGNUP TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Hi, I'm Sârra-Tilila!

I help international organizations and NGOs strengthen their integrity frameworks through internal policy development, tailored trainings, misconduct investigations, and dispute resolution. With over a decade of legal and investigative experience, I’ve worked extensively in Africa and collaborated with global giants like the World Bank and the World Food Programme.


My work is driven by a deep passion for tackling fraud and corruption while promoting transparency and accountability in international development. If you’re looking for expert support to achieve your organization’s integrity goals, let’s connect!

© 2022 par Sârra-Tilila Bounfour